Aro gTér Dzogchen and Tantra Teachings Wiki

Khandro

14 min read

Khandro

Khandro (mKha’ ‘gro) is the Tibetan for Sanskrit ḍākinī — the enlightened female principle / female tantric adept. The fuller form khandroma (mKha’ ‘gro ma) includes the explicit female ending; khandro is a common contraction. Ch.5 of Spectrum of Ecstasy supplies the etymology:

  • Kha — contraction of namkha (nam mKha’), “sky”
  • Dro — “going”, “dancing”
  • Ma — female ending

The Etymological Depth

Ch.5’s footnote 3 on the word is technically critical: “In Tibetan, the word ‘sky’ has a much broader meaning than that which we see when we look upward. Sky carries the sense of spaciousness, and is used in the same way as ‘sphere’, ‘field’ or ‘world’ in terms of all-inclusiveness. In Tantric terminology we can speak of the skies of the elements. Each element is a sky of meaning and qualities.”

Consequence: “To be able to ‘go’, move or dance in the sky, is to be free of referential coordinates — to be unbounded.”

A khandro is, structurally, a female tantric being who moves freely in the sky-of-an-element — who is unbounded, unfixed, sky-like in her manifestation. This is not a metaphor; it is the technical description of her ontological mode.

Multiple Uses in the Book

1. As a Title

Khandro is used as a Tibetan honorific title for a female Lama, parallel to Ngakpa / Ngakma for practitioners and Rinpoche for recognized teachers. Khandro Déchen — co-author of Roaring Silence and Q&A co-voice of Spectrum of Ecstasy — bears the title as a principal female Lama of the Aro gTér lineage.

2. As the Inner Energy of Each Element

Ch.5’s central technical move:

“The physical aspects of the five elements are known as the five pawos. The word ‘pawo’ means hero or warrior. This pawo characteristic applies to the dynamic qualities of the elements: the colossal enduring ruggedness of earth; the powerful surging force of water; the bright lascivious incendiary hunger of fire; the all-pervasive relentless turbulence of air; the fundamental fecundity of space. The five internal energy fields of the elements are known as the five khandros — the sky-goers. The magical appearance of the khandros reflects the spatial qualities of the elements.”

Ch.11 supplies the refined definitional clarification:

“Khandro means the glow, lustre, or ambience of the elements — their innate vividness. In terms of emotions, khandro is the feeling-tone, and pawo is the activity that is manifested out of the feeling-tone. Khandro is the atmosphere, and pawo is the way that atmosphere plays in creating its own specific direction in time.”

Ch.11 also names the lineage-source: “the Khandro-pawo-nyi-da-me-long-gyud comprises the Aro gTer teachings on khandro/pawo reflection, and relationship as spiritual practice” (footnote 8).

The Pawo / Khandro polarity (Ch.5 + Ch.11 refined):

  • Pawo = physical / dynamic / outer / hero-warrior / masculine aspect; the actual physical elements, their dynamism; the activity manifested from the feeling-tone; the way atmosphere plays in creating its own specific direction in time
  • Khandro = spatial / feeling / inner / sky-goer / feminine aspect; the glow, lustre, or ambience of the elements, their innate vividness; the feeling-tone; the atmosphere

They are not separate beings but two complementary sides of each element’s energy. Together they constitute the element’s full presentation. Ch.11: “whatever can be seen as pawo, can also be seen as khandro. The beauty of entering this view, is that it can never be frozen.”

The Dance — The Non-Dual Relationship

Ch.11 supplies the technical definition of dance in “the dance of the khandros and pawos”:

“Dance describes the nature of reality, in terms of the oscillation of unitary reality with multiplistic reality. It also describes the way in which non-duality can be experienced as having two aspects that are not separate. If you look at two people dancing together — you have the spectacle of two people; but they are moving together. So is this singular or plural? Or is it both? Or is it both reflecting both? This is the meaning of dance.”

Dance = the structural name of the khandro-pawo non-dual relationship — two aspects of one movement; the non-duality is a specific structural relation (moving-together without losing distinction), not a collapse of distinction.

“The personalities of the khandros are the inner energy of everything it is possible for us to feel. They are the magical prism of endless inter-connectedness. This is what we are, or what we could become. Our inner elements are the khyil-khor of the khandros — the iridescent matrix of being.”

Ch.6–10 develop each element’s Khandro-Pawo pair as a full chapter titled “[Color] Khandro-Pawo Display.”

Earth Khandro — Unfolded (Ch.6)

The earth khandro is the inner spatial / feeling-quality expression of the earth element — the sky-of-earth in which unbounded equanimity moves. Where the earth-pawo is the colossal-enduring-ruggedness (mountains, harvest, geological mass), the earth-khandro is the inner warmth of intrinsic space that the ordinary perceiver misreads as hollowness and the practitioner recognises as equanimity.

Ch.6’s wisdom-closing names the earth-khandro’s mode:

“With the discovery of intrinsic space we find we really do have all that we need. With this recognition we could realise that we are already totally secure in the primordial nature of our being. We have within us the wisdom of equanimity and primordial freedom from attachment.”

The earth-khandro’s sky-of-meaning is the spaciousness that nondually is equanimity — the warm-inexhaustible interior of the element. Her dance is the sparkling-through of intrinsic space that “dissolves the conceptual ground of territorialism.”

See Wisdom of Equanimity for the full treatment of the khandro’s operational mode, and Rinchen for the long-ku-level symbol.

Water Khandro — Unfolded (Ch.7)

The water khandro is the inner spatial / feeling-quality of the water element — the sky-of-water as the undisturbed-surface-mirroring-sky mode, the cool dispassionate dawn-light, the pristine winter-landscape, the crystalline-geometry of silently falling snow. Where the water-pawo is the powerful-surging-force (lethal white water, boiling springs, freezing ice), the water-khandro is the inner reflective capacity that nondually is mirror-wisdom.

Her sky-of-meaning is the dimension in which reflection happens “equally, accurately, and without judgement” (the me-long teaching). The water-khandro’s dance is the undistracted-undistorted clarity that recognises itself once the subject-object dichotomy dissolves.

See Mirror-Wisdom for the full treatment; Me-long for the Dzogchen-specific symbol; Dorje for the formalised water-element symbol.

Fire Khandro — Unfolded (Ch.8)

The fire khandro is the inner spatial / feeling-quality of the fire element — the sky-of-fire as the dimension of discriminating awareness / pure-appropriateness / the “passion beyond passion” that IS compassion. Where the fire-pawo is the “bright lascivious incendiary hunger” at its full dynamic phase-space (hearth-fire, sun, stars, surgical laser-precision), the fire-khandro is the inner spatial quality of already-operative intimate-contact — the dimension in which “we are already in coital union with every nuance of phenomenal reality.”

Her sky-of-meaning is the open dimension in which “we already possess everything simply through being sentient” — the recognition that the sense of isolation was a misreading of this already-connected condition. The fire-khandro’s dance is desireless-desire — desire liberated from the desire-for-something, extending “to accommodate the desires of everyone and everything everywhere.”

See Discriminating Awareness for the wisdom; Pema for the iconographic symbol (lotus); Fear of Isolation for the misreading the khandro’s recognition dissolves.

Air Khandro — Unfolded (Ch.9)

The air khandro is the inner spatial / feeling-quality of the air element — the sky-of-air as the dimension in which all-accomplishing wisdom is operative as the felt-mode of consciousness. Where the air-pawo is the “all-pervasive relentless turbulence” at its full dynamic phase-space (breeze, hurricane, whirlwind, lightning), the air-khandro is the inner spatial quality of self-accomplishing activity — the mode in which one’s activity arises fresh from emptiness moment-to-moment, free of the surveillance-consumption that air-neurosis ordinarily runs.

Her sky-of-meaning is the dimension in which “trust in the spaciousness of what we are” (Ch.9) is the operative mode — the gaps between moments trusted as the source of fresh-arising rather than feared as obliteration-edges. The air-khandro’s dance is the non-deliberative unhindered direct-action that the thunderbolt-sword symbolises and Dorje Trollo demonstrates.

Specific iconographic connection: Ch.9 names the air-awareness-being Dorje Trollo — “thunderbolt wrath” — whose tigress-mount is “the passionate space of Dorje Trollo’s inner khandro, as a manifestation of Tashi Chhi-‘dren or Yeshe Tsogyel” (per the Aro gTér’s Khyungchen Aro Lingma reading; the footnote-5 lineage-variance preserves the alternate Bonpo sky-tiger reading of Chogyal Namkha’i Norbu Rinpoche’s lineage). The tigress-as-inner-khandro is the most-dangerous form of tigress — pregnant or newly-calved — whose protective-ferocity-on-behalf-of-cubs is the inner-feminine partner whose passionate-space is the ground Dorje Trollo’s air-wisdom-activity operates from.

See All-Accomplishing Wisdom for the wisdom; Thunderbolt Sword for the iconographic symbol; Fear of Obliteration for the misreading the khandro’s recognition dissolves; Dorje Trollo for the awareness-being directly associated.

Space Khandro — Unfolded (Ch.10)

The space khandro is the inner spatial / feeling-quality of the space element — the sky-of-space as the dimension in which dharmadhātu wisdom is operative as the felt-mode of consciousness. Where the space-pawo is the “fundamental fecundity” of space as the generative-reabsorbing ground, the space-khandro is the inner spatial quality of unlimited-intelligence-in-unbounded-space — the mode in which consciousness is the open dimension itself, without content-to-maintain.

Her sky-of-meaning is the dimension in which “let go and let be” (Ch.10) is the operative mode — no specific recognition-move but the resting-in-what-is-already-the-case. The space-khandro’s dance is the ubiquitous intelligence in all-encompassing space: the knowing-character that never-left-being-present even while the space-neurosis was running its virtual-insentience operation.

Ground-position: unlike the other four khandros (who are specific inner-energy-modes of their elements), the space-khandro is the inner-dimension-itself in which the other four khandros operate. This is the khandro-register correlate of space’s Ch.10 dual-position (“both an element, and the empty potential from which the other elements arise”).

No specific awareness-being attached at Ch.10: unlike the water-khandro’s connection to Kuntuzangmo / Yeshé Tsogyel (via me-long), fire’s connection to Padmasambhava-as-pema, and air’s connection to Dorje Trollo’s tigress-mount, Ch.10 does not install a specific awareness-being figure for the space-khandro. Consistent with the ground-register’s non-specific character — the space-khandro is the ground in which all awareness-beings appear.

Kuntuzangmo (Samantabhadrī) in the broader Aro gTér frame occupies the chö-ku (dharmakāya) position — “the naked lady of nonduality” — and could be read as the space-khandro’s fullest-realised iconographic form at the ground-register. The book does not make this identification explicitly in Ch.10; the structural-fit is apparent.

See Dharmadhatu Wisdom for the wisdom; Khorlo for the iconographic symbol; Bewilderment for the misreading the khandro’s recognition dissolves.

Ch.13 Compressed Definition

Ch.13 supplies the book’s most compressed technical-definition of khandro:

“Khandro pertains to the essence of the elements — to their intrinsic spatial quality. Khandro is the wisdom-display quality of reality — the emptiness aspect of phenomena as perceived through the material form of the phenomenal world. Khandro is the inner energy field of the elements.”

Footnote 1: “‘Sky dancer’ is a term coined by Keith Dowman.” (Title of his translation of Yeshe Tsogyel’s life, Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1984.) The term has entered general Western spiritual language “even in contexts where there is no real understanding of its meaning.”

Three-fold compressed definition:

  • Khandro = essence of the elements (their intrinsic spatial quality)
  • Khandro = wisdom-display quality of reality (emptiness aspect of phenomena as perceived through material form)
  • Khandro = inner energy field of the elements

The Vow of the Male Tantrika

Ch.13: “Male tantrikas take the vow to view the phenomenal world as female — as wisdom-display, as the play of emptiness.”

Gendered practice-vow: the male tantrika vows to see-phenomena-as-khandro — as wisdom-display. This is not about social-gender-role but about the symbolic-Tantric perception-reorientation.

Androcentric Bias — Why Pawo Is Rarely Mentioned

Ch.13 Q&A addresses the historical over-emphasis on khandro (and under-emphasis on pawo):

“Tibetan Buddhism is almost entirely represented by men, and men — especially monks — who would not be particularly interested in practices for women… the androcentric bias of Buddhism has existed right from the beginning. But that’s a product of culture, not the teaching of Padmasambhava or Yeshe Tsogyel.”

KD: “This is why pawo is very rarely mentioned; the emphasis is always on khandro. This is quite natural given the cultural bias within Tibet, and the form orientation of the world in general.”

The three-roots-of-Tantra formula “Lama, yidam and khandro” is, per NR, “not coherent in Tantra… It only reflects the practice from a male point of view. From the female point of view it would have to be Lama, yidam and pawo.” The full coherent form is Lama / Yidam / Pawo-Khandro.

3. As Visionary Wisdom-Being

At the long-ku level, the khandros appear as visionary wisdom-beings — female enlightened figures like Yeshé Tsogyel and Kuntuzangmo. In this mode they function as yidams for sadhana practice.

In the Aro gTér specifically, Kuntuzangmo is the chö-ku (dharmakāya) khandro — “the naked lady of nonduality.” Yeshé Tsogyel holds the lineage-origin position as “the Dzogchen Buddha … being the origin of the gTérma cycles taught by Aro Lingma” (Roaring Silence - Introduction).

Khandro-Pawo as Five-fold Symmetry

Each of the five elements has its own Khandro-Pawo pair:

ElementColorChapter
EarthYellowCh.6 Yellow Khandro-Pawo Display
WaterWhiteCh.7 White Khandro-Pawo Display
FireRedCh.8 Red Khandro-Pawo Display
AirGreenCh.9 Green Khandro-Pawo Display
SpaceBlueCh.10 Blue Khandro-Pawo Display

The specific names and iconographic details of each Khandro and Pawo are developed in those chapters. Ch.1 introduces the framework compressed; the individual khandros are not named until later.

Ch.5’s “Wisdom Sisters” Framing

Ch.5’s epigraph: “The personalities of the khandros, or wisdom sisters, are the inner energy of everything it is possible for us to feel. This is what we are, or what we could become.”

This is the book’s strongest statement of the khandros’ status as what we are — not external beings to be venerated, but the inner energy-structure of one’s own being. Practice with the khandros is practice with one’s own elemental nature under its visionary-wisdom aspect.

Graph View

Backlinks